Lancia Motor Club

Model Technical and Interest => Aurelia => Topic started by: Kevin MacBride on 24 February, 2014, 10:10:36 PM



Title: Could have been worse !!!
Post by: Kevin MacBride on 24 February, 2014, 10:10:36 PM
Last year I did a race at Bishopscourt 'up North' (as we say over here). Originally an old WW2 airfield, it had been used as a racetrack for years, then the military 'took it back', but over the past few years it has reverted back to racetrack again. My first time there, its a very fast track, with long straights and sweeping bends with the odd chicane. A good run for the Aurelia I thought.
However, on the day (weekend) we had torrential rain and biting wind. During practise the car seemed a little off power. I didn't think too much about it as I was more concerned with a leaking roof on my car transporter, an old double cab Transit (which doubled as a bed for the weekend)
Race started ok, I actually was ahead for about half a lap, when a Healey Silverstone went thundering past, Ah, I says to myself, I'll follow him and get used to the track....then the heavens opened...and my wipers failed.....
Not that the wipers would have made much difference, but a good excuse for later. 3rd on the day, happy enough.
Next event was Mondello a few weeks later, and I was about 6/7 seconds a lap slower than usual. A quick check revealed nothing, all plugs were sparking, but the car still felt odd, and there was a distinct 'ping' sound from somewhere. When I got the car home, I did a quick compression test, one cylinder was showing zero. I covered the car up, and left it there.......till today.
And this is what I found.....


Title: Re: Could have been worse !!!
Post by: Parisien on 24 February, 2014, 10:25:01 PM
Whatever it is Kevin, it doesn't look good, do fill us in and is it a straightforward fix?

P


Title: Re: Could have been worse !!!
Post by: the.cern on 24 February, 2014, 11:25:19 PM
A broken push rod I presume Kevin, what a beast. I presume from what you have written there is no other damage, that is a relief.

I am surprised the compression test showed zero, I would have expected the associated valve to remain closed, or do you think it was high spot to high spot on the two broken parts of the push rod holding the valve open?

Anyway, I hope it will soon be repaired and back on the road and track.

Best wishes,

                Andy


Title: Re: Could have been worse !!!
Post by: chriswgawne on 25 February, 2014, 04:31:19 AM
Kevin,
You make it sound like the broken pushrod is the extent of the problem......... and I hope you are correct. Is the head off and does the offending valve open and close fully and smoothly when operated manually?
 I don't understand the complete lack of compression on that cylinder and if it were me, knowing that it was an engine for racing I would take this opportunity to  have a close look at the other pushrods at the very least.
Chris


Title: Re: Could have been worse !!!
Post by: the.cern on 25 February, 2014, 07:58:19 AM
Chris, are you on the night shift, or do you, like me, wake in the middle of the night and mull over the days events and tasks for the morning??

                             Andy


Title: Re: Could have been worse !!!
Post by: Kevin MacBride on 25 February, 2014, 08:05:04 AM
It's the inlet valve an cylinder three. The little steel cap on the valve had popped off (and was stuck in a pool of oil in a corner of the head). This allowed the valve to stay closed as there was extra clearance between rocker and valve.
The valve will open and close easily by hand, so I assume all is well. All I can do now is replace the pushrod, and see what happens.


Title: Re: Could have been worse !!!
Post by: chugga boom on 25 February, 2014, 08:21:13 AM

I am surprised the compression test showed zero, I would have expected the associated valve to remain closed, or do you think it was high spot to high spot on the two broken parts of the push rod holding the valve open?


Just from past experience with a collapsed lifter in a cvh engine, if the valve is shut all the time, gas cannot move in or out of the cylinder to be compressed hense no compression, used to be normal on Vauxhall ohv engines when the rockers snapped and like I said on cvh engines where the hydrolic lifters collapsed, sounds totally illogical but true  ;)


Title: Re: Could have been worse !!!
Post by: the.cern on 25 February, 2014, 09:35:35 AM
Thank you James, you live and learn !!!!!

Let us hope that all will be well with a new push rod. If, as Kevin states, the valve moves freely, then there is a real chance of the limited damage shown.

                           Andy


Title: Re: Could have been worse !!!
Post by: chriswgawne on 25 February, 2014, 10:11:25 AM
I can't have any secrets Andy can I? I am about 8,000 miles from the UK in a SE direction so an 8 hour time difference.
Sounds like Kevin might be lucky with this one but why did the pushrod break in the first place? This is puzzling me.
Chris


Title: Re: Could have been worse !!!
Post by: Kevin MacBride on 25 February, 2014, 11:06:01 AM
The rod seems to be broken just at the oil drain holes, so maybe they developed a crack. I also thought that possibly the adjusting screw may have worked loose, then with more clearance the rod could have 'bounced' and maybe dislodged itself from its position and snapped.
I'm going to chance fitting a new one anyway and see what happens. I have plans to overhaul the engine at some stage. I recently acquired a camshaft from Tim Burrett, which requires modified pistons, which in turn will probably require liners and a whole heap of other parts.
I actually left the cam in the car over the Christmas season, thinking some Lancia loving Elves would surprise me, but alas..no..!


Title: Re: Could have been worse !!!
Post by: JohnMillham on 25 February, 2014, 11:47:40 AM
Back in the 1960s when I ran a 3rd. series B20, I had a couple of the push rod ends come loose. Harry supplied new push rods which we left on his Valour stove to warm up for ten minutes before tapping in the ends. I seem to remember that engine overheating was the cause of the problem.
 Regards, John


Title: Re: Could have been worse !!!
Post by: Kevin MacBride on 25 February, 2014, 11:20:48 PM
Thanks for the replies, all I can do is wait for a new rod, and see what happens. I swapped over the pushrod, and the valve opens and closes properly, plus all the other tappet clearances were fine, so hopefully its just a freak incident. I was speaking with Peter Harding and he tells me he fits new rods often enough. If fact he'd just fitted the last ones he had in stock when I called.
I know people like to see photos of 'the oily bits', so here's the exposed cylinder head.


Title: Re: Could have been worse !!!
Post by: Richard Fridd on 26 February, 2014, 08:17:26 AM
Is that a special exhaust manifold Kevin? Best of luck with the work.


Title: Re: Could have been worse !!!
Post by: DavidLaver on 26 February, 2014, 10:50:03 AM

I'd forgotten how the rocker carriers curve.  However I can remember how they wear...  Yours all ok?

Is the heater blanked off?  I'd have thought even racing a bit of warmth up the screen would be handy in such a "lush green land" as you live in.  I also used to make full use of the heated rear screen in mine, and even after new front and rear screen seals and the inside being bone dry.

David


Title: Re: Could have been worse !!!
Post by: Kevin MacBride on 26 February, 2014, 06:58:20 PM
I got the manifold from Peter Harding some eight years ago now. As regards the heating (or lack of it), its pure laziness....after I'd restored the bodywork I was in a rush to get the car driving, and I simply never refitted the heater. Every time I'm sitting, strapped into the seat, with a fogged up screen, I'm reminded of the missing heater. And whenever I consider fitting it, I'm usually being handed a paint brush, or a pair of kids, or even a lawnmower......


Title: Re: Could have been worse !!!
Post by: Niels Jonassen on 27 February, 2014, 06:54:52 PM
How did you get the little bit which had broken off out of the engine? I can see that the push rod is broken at the lower end. I hope that you have not fitted the push rods upside down.


Title: Re: Could have been worse !!!
Post by: Kevin MacBride on 27 February, 2014, 11:50:46 PM
How did you get the little bit which had broken off out of the engine? I can see that the push rod is broken at the lower end. I hope that you have not fitted the push rods upside down.

A retractable magnet !

Car is running today, and everything seems ok. There is a show on this weekend and I'm putting the car on the Lancia stand. Unfortunately when I checked the tracking delivery from Cavalitto, it indicated that I would not get the parts till Tuesday.
Soooooo, a bit of lateral thing was required.
Early Fiat 500's have a very similar pushrod (126's have a solid rod). The 500 part is maybe 4mm longer, and the inerts are slightly different. I removed my inserts, and the 500 ones, cut down the rod to the correct length, and fitted the B20 inserts.
So now there is a little bit of Fiat beating away inside a Lancia, or once again Fiat comes to Lancias rescue !!!

As soon as I get the correct parts, I'll remove and check everything over again. I just need the car running to make it easier to attend the show.


Title: Re: Could have been worse !!!
Post by: simonandjuliet on 28 February, 2014, 07:41:51 AM
Good bit of "Heath Robinson" .....


Title: Re: Could have been worse !!!
Post by: Parisien on 28 February, 2014, 08:17:08 AM
....prefer to use the term resourceful.......!


Temporary fixes are the life blood of some cars, hoping it properly fixed and leading an even more adventurous life again very soon.



P


Title: Re: Could have been worse !!!
Post by: the.cern on 28 February, 2014, 04:38:17 PM
In my experience some, if not all, temporary fixes end up being the permanent fixes!!!!!

Great ingenuity and a good knowledge of other models to the rescue ..... well done. Have a great weekend, I hope the sun shines on you.

                                         Andy


Title: Re: Could have been worse !!!
Post by: DavidLaver on 28 February, 2014, 09:51:02 PM

How do they compare?   Might you pull the other five and replace with FIAT items?

David


Title: Re: Could have been worse !!!
Post by: Kevin MacBride on 28 February, 2014, 10:30:20 PM
I was speaking with another friend today at the show. He has (had, now retired) a light engineering company. His son now runs the operation. He machines alloy based components for various companies, CNC and water jet cutting. I asked him about the rods. He said that the price Cavalitto was charging was as good as he's be able to do them for, but he was more concerned as to why it failed in the first place. He said, that if it was his car, he'd fit a complete new set regardless. What concerned him was the two little oil holes. When I had the rocket block off, I had a look at the exhaust pushrod, and I was certain I could feel an ever so gentle 'bump' just to each side of the hole, like a compression bulge. I wonder if 60 odd years of tappeting could be causing this. The oil hole must be there for a reason, yet the Fiat rod was plain, and just had a hole in the centre of each end insert, the same as the B20.
In modern Fiat engines, mostly diesels, the rockers are designed to break in the event of a timing belt failure, cheaper and easier to fix than damaged valves and pistons. I wonder are the holes the same idea, as in better for a rod to break (and so the valve stays shut), rather than run the risk of a piston hitting a stuck valve.
Has anyone ever had a timing chain fail on an Aurelia ?


Title: Re: Could have been worse !!!
Post by: Kevin MacBride on 09 March, 2014, 11:33:38 PM
In my experience some, if not all, temporary fixes end up being the permanent fixes!!!!!

Great ingenuity and a good knowledge of other models to the rescue ..... well done. Have a great weekend, I hope the sun shines on you.

                                         Andy

New pushrods arrived on Friday last......still in the packaging......I'll lay odds they'll be there for a while yet !!