Well, we've had a few days to mull over over the implications of FIAT's leaked Operation Football and I'm surprised there haven't been more comments on here. I suppose the demise of Lancia as a brand comes as no surprise to many of us, no matter how much we'd like to see our beloved marque continue. There are lots of posts on lots of other forums, UK, European and US based, with varying opinions about what FIAT should do. Some posters openly call for Lancia to be scrapped and which cite factually incorrect info. I think that most probably one of the most crucial elements in this scenario (and for Lancia's potential survival) is what GM and subsequently FIAT-Opel choose to do with SAAB.
For the record here's what I think FIAT-Opel should do, in an ideal Lancia-phile who also likes SAAB's kind of world....
FIAT and Opel survive as two separate mainstream brands, with significant sharing of platforms, drivetrains and production capacity. There are already suggestions that Grande Punto production will move to Russelsheim and Italian plants will close. FIAT and Opel brands concentrate on their main European market and developing countries such as India, Africa and South America. There are similar rumours of what'll be left of GM USA working with FIAT in such markets. Vauxhall would go as a brand - they'll close Ellesmere Port and Luton anyway, so there'll be no UK content in the Opel brand.
Ferrari and Maserati continue in their current roles as halo brands.
Alfa Romeo survive as the mainstream 'sporting' brand, with the odd halo model (eg 8C), supported by models in most segments. FIAT have invested too much into AR to do otherwise and they have an established share in most markets including China. Alfa Romeo used to enter the US market through Chrysler dealerships. Possible platform sharing for large Alfas and Chryslers. I can see UK AR dealerships selling Maserati and Chrysler also.
Abarth as the motorsport-based brand, using both FIAT derived and Abarth only models, if the rumours of an Elise based Abarth sports car are anything to be believed. Abarth remains the motorsport hub of the combined FIAT-Opel empire, ie rallying, Touring Cars, GTs. Production cars sold through FIAT and Opel dealerships
Lancia and SAAB are merged to form a new brand, with a real focus on developing emerging technologies (hydrogen fuel cells, aerodynamics) that are trialled in small scale production and then filtered down to the rest of the FIAT-Opel brands. Lancia-SAAB (or Saab-Lancia, which I think sounds and reads better) offers models that are techniclally more advanced, are more 'cutting edge' to the point of being a bit 'left-field' and offer higher levels of luxury, interior design and comfort than its sister brands. I'd like to see a real focus on safety and driveability, utilising both SAAB and Lancia's past glories as pioneers in FWD and turbocharging. If you go a step further and add Jeep and it's 4WD expertise and IMHO the only real value brand in Chrysler, you've got potential for an interesting blend of technologies and histories. Adding Jeep would also bring with it US dealerships. That would give SAAB-Lancia/Jeep a model range that went from Ypsilon to Grand Cherokee, hopefully differentiated enough to stand apart from FIAT, Opel, Alfa Romeo and Chrysler.
If the worst comes true and Lancia is for the chop, we must lobby Sig. Marchionne to allow Lancia to finish with a flourish - a limited run of the oft-promised Fulvia and a big engined RWD Aurelia GT.
Any thoughts?